Campaigns · · 4 min read
Tougher water penalties are law on paper. What would they change on the Dart?
The Water (Special Measures) Act promises faster, tougher penalties for water companies, but most of them still need regulations that haven’t been published. What they would change for dry spills, emergency overflows and late reporting on the Dart.

The Water (Special Measures) Act became law on 24 February 2025. Twenty-one months later parts of it are working, the section on emergency overflows has not started, and the new penalties ministers promised still need regulations that have yet to be published. We have been through the Act and the consultations to see where things stand, and what they would mean for the problems we have been reporting here.
Some of it is in force. Ofwat can block executive bonuses, and the government says £4 million was stopped across six companies in 2025. Executives who obstruct an Environment Agency investigation can go to prison. Since June 2025 every company, South West Water included, has had to publish a yearly plan for reducing pollution incidents.
The penalties are the part to watch. In July the government confirmed that the Agency would be able to fine a water company up to £500,000 on the balance of probabilities, without proving a criminal case. It would also have to issue an automatic penalty of £20,000 (£10,000 if paid within 28 days) each time one of seven things happens. Three of them touch our recent work: an emergency overflow discharging more than three times in a year, a spill monitor working for less than 90% of the year, and a significant pollution incident not reported within four hours.
Start with speed. On 29 September South West Water was fined £7.86 million at Plymouth Magistrates’ Court after admitting 18 charges. The offences dated from 2015 to 2021, so the gap between a spill and its penalty was between five and eleven years. One of them was a pumping station at Hooe Lake that discharged for 88 hours over a bank holiday weekend in 2020. Under the new rules a company gets a notice, has 28 days to respond, and pays.
We have a smaller example closer to home. In our piece on dry-weather spills we said we wrote to the Environment Agency about Rattery, Kilbury, Scorriton and Harbertonford. The reply came on 11 November. The Agency inspected Rattery on 22 April and issued its compliance reports on 8 June, with actions due in July. By November South West Water had still not explained the cause or the remedy, and the outcome so far is a site warning. The Agency also told us it does not investigate individual dry spills, that dry spills from before 2025 will not be looked at, and that its formal investigations at Rattery, Scorriton and Harbertonford will finish in March 2028.
Would the new penalties help? A dry spill is a breach of permit, and the government’s consultation named dry day spills as something the £500,000 civil penalty is meant for. That lowers the bar of proof considerably. It does nothing about willingness to look: a penalty still needs someone at the Agency to open a case, and dry spills are not one of the seven automatic triggers. We count 2,983 of them on the Dart since 2020. River Hub tracks ongoing dry spills automatically.
Emergency overflows are different, because one of the automatic triggers is aimed straight at them. We reported on 9 November that the Dart’s 18 emergency overflows discharged for about 5,171 hours between 2020 and 2025. Blackrock, at Buckfast, has discharged for more than 130 hours in every year since its monitor was fitted. On any ordinary reading that is more than three discharges a year, four years running.
Here the open questions start. What counts as one “emergency discharge”? South West Water told us it does not record whether a discharge happened in emergency conditions. Does each overflow count separately? The Agency can waive a penalty in “exceptional circumstances”, a phrase nobody has defined and which, under the plans, could not be appealed. Does a pump failure qualify? A power cut? The Agency is due to publish its enforcement policy around the end of December.
The Act would not make these discharges public either. The section requiring emergency overflow spills to be reported within an hour is the one that has not been commenced. Monitors are expected on half of these outlets by March 2030 and all of them by April 2035. Until then the data would go to the Agency monthly, and the rest of us would keep finding out through information requests.
The four-hour rule connects to something else we covered. The regulators’ joint report found South West Water reported only 71% of its own pollution incidents in 2025. Late reporting of a significant incident would carry an automatic penalty.
And in our piece on the ten spill promise we said that once a spill limit is written into a permit, the Agency can enforce it with powers from this Act. Those are the powers described here, and they are not yet usable.
None of this can happen until regulations are approved by both Houses of Parliament. As of 18 November we could not find a draft, and the government’s only timetable is “when Parliamentary time allows”. A new Environment Secretary took over two weeks after the penalties were confirmed, and regulations like these cannot be amended once laid.
Will a £20,000 fine actually change behaviour at a company just fined £7.86 million? Serious cases will still go to court. What the new penalties offer is a consequence for the Blackrocks: the repeated, lower-level failures that today produce a warning letter months later, or nothing.
We will report back when the Agency publishes its policy, and again when a draft appears.

