Campaigns · · 7 min read
The new water fines, counted: what they would cost on the Dart and across the region
We counted what the new automatic water fines would have cost on the Dart in 2025, and across South West Water. The dry spills that matter most are not an automatic trigger at all. Part three of our series on what River Hub can show.

This is the third post in our series on what River Hub can show. Part one looked at sewage spilling when it hasn’t rained, and part two at emergency overflows, the spills nobody is shown. This time we take the government’s new water fines, the ones making headlines as a crackdown, and do the arithmetic the headlines skip. Using River Hub, what would they have cost, first on the Dart and then across South West Water, and what would they leave untouched?
On 18 November we wrote about the new penalties in principle. Here we put numbers to them. The penalties are not yet in force and will not apply to past spills, so these figures show what the regime would have meant had it been in place. They are not money anyone owes.
Two kinds of fine
The Water (Special Measures) Act 2025 creates two routes. The first is an automatic penalty of £20,000, or £10,000 if paid within 28 days, each time one of seven specific things happens. They include an emergency overflow discharging more than three times in a year, a spill monitor working for less than 90% of the year, and a serious pollution incident not reported within four hours. There is no court case: a company gets a notice, has 28 days, and pays.
The second is a civil penalty of up to £500,000, which the Environment Agency can impose “on the balance of probabilities” for other breaches, without proving a criminal case. This is where dry-weather spilling would come in. The difference matters, as we’ll see.
What the automatic fines would have cost on the Dart in 2025
Two of the seven automatic triggers are things River Hub already measures. We counted them for the Dart in 2025:
- Emergency overflows discharging more than three times: four. Blackrock at Buckfast (25 discharges), Dart Bridge, Darthaven Marina and South Town in Dartmouth.
- Monitors working less than 90% of the year: two. Shinners Bridge at Dartington (89.0%) and Widecombe (89.2%).
That is six automatic penalties: £120,000, or £60,000 if South West Water paid each within 28 days. It is a floor, not a ceiling. It leaves out the other five kinds of trigger, including pollution incidents reported late: the regulators’ first joint report found South West Water reported just 71% of its own incidents in 2025. And as we explained in part two, nobody has yet defined what counts as one emergency discharge, so the emergency overflow count could move in either direction.
The problem the fines don’t reach
Dry spills are not one of the seven automatic triggers. The Dart’s clearest problem, the 2,983 discharges with no rain since 2020 that we described in part one, would earn no automatic fine at all.
They would fall instead under the £500,000 civil penalty, and the government’s consultation named dry day spills as one of the things it is for. Had the penalty been in force, fourteen of the Dart’s works dry-spilled often enough to justify a case. At the £500,000 ceiling that is a theoretical £7 million. Only the ceiling is set in law, so on more modest, illustrative penalties our modelling puts the exposure at roughly £1 million to £4 million, depending on whether a works is weighted by the number of its dry spills or by how long they lasted. The Dart’s dry spills run long, so the higher figure is the fairer one.
What would actually happen is far less certain. A civil penalty is discretionary: no case, no fine. We don’t yet know what stance the Environment Agency will take. When we asked, it told us it does not investigate individual dry spills and will not look at those from before 2025 (more on that here). That describes how it works today, before the new powers exist, and its enforcement policy, due around the end of December, may set out something different. Until it does, the real figure for the Dart could be anything from these sums to nothing.
What counts as a dry spill?
There is a step before any of that: someone has to decide what a dry spill is. River Hub uses the Environment Agency’s own one-day test: no more than 0.25 mm of rain at the nearest gauge on the day of the spill and on the day before. Nothing yet says that is the test the new penalties will use. How much rain is allowed, measured at which gauge, over how many days, and whether each discharge counts or is grouped into 12- and 24-hour blocks: every one of those choices changes the count. A looser definition could take most of the spills in part one out of reach altogether.
That makes the definition one of the most important things for river groups to engage on as the rules are drawn up. We will be pressing for one that is strict, published, and checkable by anyone against the monitoring data.
Now scale it up: the whole of South West Water
The Dart is one small catchment. Across Devon and Cornwall, more than 1,100 of South West Water’s storm overflows spilled in 2025 alone, with more than 200,000 recorded discharges, on the company’s own published monitoring data. That is roughly 26 times as many overflows as the Dart.
Scale our Dart findings up by that factor and the shape of the new regime across the region comes into focus. It is a rough extrapolation, so read these as orders of magnitude, not forecasts:
- The automatic fines would total something like £3 million a year across South West Water.
- Dry spilling, somewhere between 30,000 and 80,000 dry discharges since 2020, could carry tens of millions of pounds in theoretical civil penalties. The range is wide because one bad year at Rattery, with 1,735 dry spills in 2022, drives the top end.
Set that against what the company has actually paid. Its largest-ever penalty is the £7.86 million handed down at Plymouth Magistrates’ Court in September this year, for 18 charges spanning 2015 to 2021. One year of the new automatic fines across the region would come to roughly 40% of that, so within three years the automatic regime alone would out-fine the biggest court case in the company’s history. The dry-weather spilling carries several times that landmark fine. How much of it would ever be levied depends on the same two open questions: whether the Agency opens cases, and how a dry spill is defined.
A tough law aimed at the wrong target
That is the shape of it. The part of the regime that will bite is aimed largely at reporting and monitoring failures, and would raise real but modest sums: £120,000 on the Dart, a few million across the region. The power that could reach the actual pollution, tens of thousands of spills with no rain to excuse them, carries a paper value in the tens of millions, and a real value that depends on two things not yet decided: whether the Agency will open cases, and how a dry spill is defined. A fine only changes behaviour if it is applied.
What we are asking
We have put this to the Environment Agency alongside the evidence from part one. The Agency replied to our information request (EIR2026/48000) on 11 November. When it publishes its enforcement policy, due around the end of December, we will ask it to confirm:
- whether it will use the civil penalty for persistent dry-weather spilling at all, and if not, why the region’s worst overflows should expect no consequence
- what definition of a dry spill it will use, and that it will publish and consult on that definition before the penalties start.
Why this needs to go national
None of this counting is specific to the Dart, or even to South West Water. Every overflow in England has a monitor, every company publishes its data, and the triggers in the Act are the same everywhere. River Hub can already tell, river by river and company by company, which overflows would cross the automatic thresholds and which dry spills a civil penalty could reach. That is the like-for-like picture regulators and journalists currently cannot get. We are working to make it available to other rivers. If you’re part of a river group, or if you can donate to support this work, get in touch at hello@friendsofthedart.org.
Coming up in the series
In part four we’ll look at overflows that spill before their treatment works is even full, and whether the works can cope with the homes connected to them.

